11 Homemade Poptarts You Have To Try!

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see my policies to learn more.

Advertiser Disclosure and Policies

Love toaster pastries but hate the expense and the added sugar to your diet? Make your own homemade Poptarts instead – here’s 11 recipes to try!

Okay, so you’re not going to get the healthy mom of the year award for serving your kids Pop Tarts, but who cares? They like them and they’ll love it if you make homemade poptarts!

Not only are homemade poptarts much tastier, but, you get to feel better about serving them because you’ll know what ingredients are inside and since, I’m sure you’re not going to add chemicals or preservatives, it’s a double-win!

So, if you’re kids love eating pop tarts and you’re looking for a homemade version that isn’t full of a bunch of junk, here’s a list of 11 homemade recipes from classic to OMG!


11 Homemade Poptarts You Have to Try

Homemade Strawberry Poptarts
Image via Saving Room for Dessert

Strawberry Homemade PopTarts from Saving Room for Dessert

For all you traditionalists out there, here’s a decadent looking Strawberry Poptart recipe from Saving for Dessert. This one is so pretty, it almost looks like toy food!


Homemade S'mores Poptarts (6)
Image via Big Bear’s Wife

Homemade S’mores Poptarts from Big Bear’s Wife

Holy Chocolately Marshmallow! My girls love the S’mores Poptarts from the grocery store, but look how thick and creamy these Homemade Pop Tarts from Big Bear’s Wife are – so much more filling than store-bought.


Homemade Pop-Tarts
Image via CincyShopper

Homemade Nutella Pop Tarts from CincyShopper

Calling all Nutella Fans! Now you can have your favorite morning breakfast filled with your favorite creamy filling.


Make Homemade Blueberry Poptarts
Image via WikiHow

Blueberry Homemade Poptarts from WikiHow

Blueberry PopTarts were my favorite kind as a kid, but as an adult, I try to stay away from premade foods and so, I’m kinda anxious to try this one! I’ll let you know how they come out.


Maple-Cinnamon Oat Pop Tarts
Image via Back to the Cutting Board

Maple Cinnamon Oat Poptarts from Back to the Cutting Board

I love anything Maple and Cinnamon, so I was super excited to find this Pop Tart recipe! And since it’s made with Oats, it’s gotta be healthier…right?


how to make homemade pop tarts
Image via Cleverly & Simple

Peanut Butter & Jelly – Homemade Poptarts from Cleverly Simple

A classic lunch and breakfast had a baby and the Peanut Butter and Jelly Homemade PopTart was born! How cool would it be to bring these to school for lunch instead of plain old bread, peanut butter & jelly?! I might have to make these since my youngest daughter takes PB&J to school every.single.day.


Homemade Cherry Pop Tarts Recipe | In Jennie's Kitchen
Image via In Jennie’s Kitchen

Homemade Cherry Pop Tarts from In Jennie’s Kitchen

While, I’m not a big cherry fan, I had to include these Homemade Cherry Pop Tarts because they are so stinkin’ pretty! Plus, the husband and oldest daughter like cherries, so maybe I’ll make these one day, too.


Raspberry Homemade Poptarts
Image via Penny Pinchin’ Mom

Raspberry Homemade Poptarts from Penny Pinchin’ Mom

I have a TON of raspberries growing in my yard, so this recipe for Raspberry Homemade Poptarts couldn’t have come at a better time! These are definitely going on my list of recipes to make.


Homemade Apple Pie Poptarts
Image via raspberri cupcakes

Homemade Apple Pie Poptarts from Raspberri Cupcakes

Apple Pie for Breakfast. Is there a better way to start the day? Seriously?!


Homemade Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts Recipe
Image via Serious Eats

Brown Sugar and Cinnamon Homemade Poptarts from Serious Eats

Ahh…the husband’s favorite kind of Pop Tart. Of course, these move to the top of the list and must be made!


Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Poptarts
Image via Babble

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Homemade Poptarts from Babble

And last, but not least…O.M.G.! Sugar rush for breakfast? YES. PLEASE.  I’m not even sure these should be served for breakfast. Maybe it would be best to save these for an afternoon treat or even dessert.

I hope you’ve enjoyed checking out these super-yummy looking homemade poptarts! I know I can’t wait to try some of these recipes…the kids are going to love them!

Be sure to signup for my daily newsletter to receive free printables, easy dinner ideas, recipes, home business tips and so much more right in your inbox!

Like this post? Don’t forget to PIN IT to share with your friends:

11 Homemade Poptarts You Have to Try

11 Homemade Poptarts You Have to Try

11 Homemade Poptarts You Have to Try

11 Homemade Poptarts You Have to Try

Have a Spectacular Day!